{"requested":"democracy:33","threadKey":"council:61","generation":"8c6e3bd66423255d","total":14,"rows":[{"commentId":"s63f9332089bdb642d535ea9a","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x5ae602686c9573bff2ef0483bda7a9589bc9eb7a2e14f91296367c5785394b27","address":"134Bdvpf4EphtYv1A7Eg5QfrS9ZwGwygdN5uHzqijFjBuhzH","emoji":"🦓","emojiName":"Parakeet","emojiUrl":"https://cdn.discordapp.com/emojis/1074721851550466219.webp?size=32","tag":null,"identity":{"display":"Parakeet","verified":true,"email":"","web":"","twitter":""},"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"Mostly abstaining in protest of the tiny HDX buffer this leaves. ❤️","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-24T21:58:56.067Z","editedAt":"2023-02-25T03:21:15.014Z","revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63f9332089bdb642d535ea9a","cid":null,"height":1},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63f9c24a89bdb642d535ea9f","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x5ae602686c9573bff2ef0483bda7a9589bc9eb7a2e14f91296367c5785394b27","address":"134Bdvpf4EphtYv1A7Eg5QfrS9ZwGwygdN5uHzqijFjBuhzH","emoji":"🦓","emojiName":"Parakeet","emojiUrl":"https://cdn.discordapp.com/emojis/1074721851550466219.webp?size=32","tag":null,"identity":{"display":"Parakeet","verified":true,"email":"","web":"","twitter":""},"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"I ultimately decided to vote nay on this because I would like the see a larger buffer for HDX on future LP adds. I suggest making it so that HDX will be 6% after the LP add. ","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-25T08:09:46.150Z","editedAt":null,"revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63f9c24a89bdb642d535ea9f","cid":null,"height":2},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63f9cc7f89bdb642d535eaa2","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x8aee4e164d5d70ac67308f303c7e063e9156903e42c1087bbc530447487fa47f","address":"149AQApEw4Xe1DxWesqywiuGQHazbETMgWgT89WjEYFAc29y","emoji":"🍁","emojiName":"heimdall","emojiUrl":"https://cdn.discordapp.com/emojis/1005035405864869939.webp?size=32","tag":null,"identity":{"display":"lolmcshizz","verified":true,"email":"","web":"","twitter":"@lolmcshizz"},"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"Good morning everyone - as you can see, this liquidity add was unsuccessful!\n\nI'll leave this discussion open over the weekend to see if we can understand the reasons for it failing before moving forward in the new week.\n\nWe will also ensure more time for votes moving forward unless critical.","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-25T08:53:19.418Z","editedAt":null,"revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63f9cc7f89bdb642d535eaa2","cid":null,"height":3},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63fa1b7f89bdb642d535eaa3","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x6ab1b1ad1a47ec790398e905772a53a8105e337aef258fc5c5aef50eca36bb11","address":"13QtrzZBsCGrFcswz34nK5px6Hj3XimZafoN6VcVQRv89Jub","emoji":"🐩","tag":null,"identity":null,"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"This team does not want discussion. I just noticed the one discussion that was going on In TG chat has been muted. Silence any opinion that does not match what the team wants. This is a real problem. Don't ask for discussion and then silence it. One downvote from me for every hour the user is silenced.","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-25T14:30:23.785Z","editedAt":null,"revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63fa1b7f89bdb642d535eaa3","cid":null,"height":4},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63fa220789bdb642d535eaa4","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x8aee4e164d5d70ac67308f303c7e063e9156903e42c1087bbc530447487fa47f","address":"149AQApEw4Xe1DxWesqywiuGQHazbETMgWgT89WjEYFAc29y","emoji":"🍁","emojiName":"heimdall","emojiUrl":"https://cdn.discordapp.com/emojis/1005035405864869939.webp?size=32","tag":null,"identity":{"display":"lolmcshizz","verified":true,"email":"","web":"","twitter":"@lolmcshizz"},"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"[@7L1T...smJd](/account/7L1T9Vfb5XNe6KNB3aVH6raiorjZzGSMTvhdrZ8TaJNqsmJd) great to see you reach out!\nI'd love to understand what it was about this proposal that you voted against - this way we can see if there are improvements that can be made before it is resubmitted in the coming days.","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-25T14:58:15.255Z","editedAt":null,"revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63fa220789bdb642d535eaa4","cid":null,"height":5},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63fa236989bdb642d535eaa5","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x6ab1b1ad1a47ec790398e905772a53a8105e337aef258fc5c5aef50eca36bb11","address":"13QtrzZBsCGrFcswz34nK5px6Hj3XimZafoN6VcVQRv89Jub","emoji":"🐩","tag":null,"identity":null,"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"[@lolmcshizz](/account/7Ljigfve9PdRqvSjiRGUjVf37rbX3n89ZmaitD2hQQhtLBMN) You stopped honest discussion on the chat this morning. Muting users is a way of hiding agendas. I will vote no on all proposals moving forward if the mute is not removed. You personally muted that user. Very offensive.","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-25T15:04:09.995Z","editedAt":null,"revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63fa236989bdb642d535eaa5","cid":null,"height":6},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63fa2a0989bdb642d535eaa6","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x8aee4e164d5d70ac67308f303c7e063e9156903e42c1087bbc530447487fa47f","address":"149AQApEw4Xe1DxWesqywiuGQHazbETMgWgT89WjEYFAc29y","emoji":"🍁","emojiName":"heimdall","emojiUrl":"https://cdn.discordapp.com/emojis/1005035405864869939.webp?size=32","tag":null,"identity":{"display":"lolmcshizz","verified":true,"email":"","web":"","twitter":"@lolmcshizz"},"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"[@7L1T...smJd](/account/7L1T9Vfb5XNe6KNB3aVH6raiorjZzGSMTvhdrZ8TaJNqsmJd) with respect - I did not mute any discussion, I muted an individual (for 24H) who after hours of discussion was seemingly still not understanding and failing to make a point - it was incredibly disruptive to other users using the channel to seek support.\n\nThe discussion is still visible for all to see.\n\nIt would be useful if you could clearly state your reasons for rejecting the proposal so that we can identify any needed areas for improvement :)","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-25T15:32:25.717Z","editedAt":null,"revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63fa2a0989bdb642d535eaa6","cid":null,"height":7},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63fa332389bdb642d535eaa8","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x845b9f9c9c225ee4db55aae9b1262de3487e0345d9b60208de3040784c0dc147","address":"13zYYEzHJbZyZwAewLTfrLgcaLnx4Dprx1oe44TXJmUZHVVx","emoji":"🐱","tag":null,"identity":null,"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"[@7L1T...smJd](/account/7L1T9Vfb5XNe6KNB3aVH6raiorjZzGSMTvhdrZ8TaJNqsmJd) 🤡🤡🤡\n\n”Hello Mr G” might have been the most uninformed “investor” I’ve ever seen. If we could enact governance to permanently mute that tg account I think it would unanimously pass. ","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-25T16:11:15.478Z","editedAt":null,"revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63fa332389bdb642d535eaa8","cid":null,"height":8},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63fa4f5c89bdb642d535eaab","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x5ae602686c9573bff2ef0483bda7a9589bc9eb7a2e14f91296367c5785394b27","address":"134Bdvpf4EphtYv1A7Eg5QfrS9ZwGwygdN5uHzqijFjBuhzH","emoji":"🦓","emojiName":"Parakeet","emojiUrl":"https://cdn.discordapp.com/emojis/1074721851550466219.webp?size=32","tag":null,"identity":{"display":"Parakeet","verified":true,"email":"","web":"","twitter":""},"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"[@7L1T...smJd](/account/7L1T9Vfb5XNe6KNB3aVH6raiorjZzGSMTvhdrZ8TaJNqsmJd) @lolmcshizz I do not have telegram. Can you share that discussion here? ","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-25T18:11:40.174Z","editedAt":"2023-02-25T18:12:47.933Z","revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63fa4f5c89bdb642d535eaab","cid":null,"height":9},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63fa88b589bdb642d535eaae","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x6ab1b1ad1a47ec790398e905772a53a8105e337aef258fc5c5aef50eca36bb11","address":"13QtrzZBsCGrFcswz34nK5px6Hj3XimZafoN6VcVQRv89Jub","emoji":"🐩","tag":null,"identity":null,"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"[@7Lb6...21YU](/account/7Lb6pk6gWvfmQdeszstAe7SPHuoUWmVeqGhup7yVUdwH21YU) \nI am curious, what was he misinformed about?  If you read what i read, The concern revolves around POL liquidity fee's collected and not returned to the token holders. According to the discussion, the token holders are the DAO, The DAO owns the liquidity, why would the earnings of the POL not be returned or shared with the Token holders? Even I would like to know this.","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-25T22:16:21.282Z","editedAt":null,"revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63fa88b589bdb642d535eaae","cid":null,"height":10},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63faa26e89bdb642d535eaaf","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x5ae602686c9573bff2ef0483bda7a9589bc9eb7a2e14f91296367c5785394b27","address":"134Bdvpf4EphtYv1A7Eg5QfrS9ZwGwygdN5uHzqijFjBuhzH","emoji":"🦓","emojiName":"Parakeet","emojiUrl":"https://cdn.discordapp.com/emojis/1074721851550466219.webp?size=32","tag":null,"identity":{"display":"Parakeet","verified":true,"email":"","web":"","twitter":""},"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"Someone shared the telegram chat log with me. \n\nHere it is:\n\n`Hello MR G, [2/25/2023 5:49 AM]\nI have not seen any attempt by the team to get these assets here on chain organically as they swap for hdx and cause price to increase. I understand you were carpet bombed, governance checks do bring reality back close. All of those assets are on chain currently, how does it help to add more when trade volume is low?\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 5:54 AM]\nhave great liquidity so that there is no slippage in the assets that people usually own more, of course it matters\n\nYou have the ground prepared for what is coming is part of the strategy\n\nWhat is the point then that the price of hdx is $1, if the other assets cannot take a trade of $1000\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 5:55 AM]\nAdding to Jose's comment, team is not swapping for HDX. Idk where you're getting that from\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 5:55 AM]\nlittle by little we will add more native assets, such as ASTAR\n\nand most likely ZTG too, USDT from statemint, iBTC\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 5:59 AM]\nthis was not adding a new asset, or a new bridge. Acala cannot even get their stable coin to re-peg. I have money locked on an exchange in AUSD that cannot be moved until they clean up the exploit mess. Kucoin is holding me hostage.\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 6:00 AM]\nacala is just the  connection between wormhole  and us\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:02 AM]\nMaybe re-read the referendum\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:03 AM]\n\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:04 AM]\nIs this correct?\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:04 AM]\nwhy does the dex volume not report?\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 6:04 AM]\nCause the APIs in format that they want, not are done yet\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 6:05 AM]\nI think so, is the  volume from kraken\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:07 AM]\nsite say about 160k in 24h volume\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:07 AM]\nor a little more\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:08 AM]\nwith 5m in locked assets, I dont see a big shortage in liquidity?\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:08 AM]\nWhat\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:09 AM]\nCan you clarify this and the point you're trying to make? It's unclear\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:12 AM]\nHow does the liquidity providers currently continue to be rewarded a % of the swap fee's when the amount on chain is diluted? Is this not understood. You are removing the reward when you add liquidity to 90% higher than trade volume\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:13 AM]\nif they own 1% now, soon 1/2 %\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:14 AM]\n1. we are following the POL diversification and deployment plan as outlined here in this referendum, which was voted on and approved through governance:\n[Democracy referendum #18](/referendum/democracy/18)\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:15 AM]\n2: Yes, individual LPs are competing with POL LP\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:16 AM]\nSo one perspective to have is your perspective: \"My LP is being diluted by POL LP\"\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:17 AM]\nanother perspective to have is OUR LP is earning LP rewards\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:17 AM]\nYield is what brings money on chain from new users\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:19 AM]\nOur team is looking for a 5m wage contract, where does the pol lp rewards go? certainly not back to we the investors? Or am I wrong?\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:22 AM]\nSure attractive yields helps usher in new money, and so does an attractive service like low slippage, omnidirectional swaps, and depth of liquidity. That being said, there will be liquidity incentives soonTM\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:23 AM]\nFees earned through POL LP are held and owned by the DAO. I know there are some cool ideas in the works to distribute fees to holders\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:24 AM]\nSo there's a balance, how much do you want to distribute out fees earned vs how much do you want the DAO to continue to earn and build firepower\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:24 AM]\nthis is a young protocol, how we grow it is up to us\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:25 AM]\nI want you to think of the patience of the token holders in this group, I dont get the sense that token price appreciation is a priority. I dont know about about the DAO, can you tell me things the DAO has done with the existing fee's its collected?\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:25 AM]\ni'm supportive of all ideas and proposals that grow and sustain the protocol for the long run. The long run may look like jogs and intermittent sprints in between\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 6:26 AM]\nWe are the dao sir\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:26 AM]\nI am a patient token holder in the group, pls don't exclude me from that\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:26 AM]\nYes, You are a voter\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 6:27 AM]\nthe fees currently remain at the same LP, there is no way to remove them without withdrawing the liquidity, which will not be done\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:27 AM]\nLong time holder, since the beginning as well\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:28 AM]\nYou dodged the question, what has been done as a community benefit with fee's collected so far for the benefit of the DAO\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:28 AM]\nser we can do anything, you got a proposal? send it through\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:28 AM]\nyou got good ideas, bringum up\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:28 AM]\nlets get you funded\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:29 AM]\nYou suggested earlier we had received a benefit, was just asking what it was?\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:29 AM]\npls pull my quote\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:30 AM]\nSo there's a balance, how much do you want to distribute out fees earned vs how much do you want the DAO to continue to earn and build firepower\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:30 AM]\nfirepower is money used to make a change or benefit\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:31 AM]\n\"firepower\" in that sentence referring to growing our stack to fund future costs/endeavors as a DAO\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:32 AM]\nlike how a business would make money and reinvest it back into themselves\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:32 AM]\npropelling for future long term growth, not so focused on shortermism growth\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:32 AM]\nTeam is not being paid by fees but if you read the article it says the budget came from rounds of fundings. It lasted around two years and it helped created the solid foundation of the Dex, the backend, notably, which is now a V1. \n\nThe funds collected during the LBP are protocol owned liquidity. The team doesn't touch it themselves. Mostbof the Liquidity will be added to the Dex so we can trade comfortably. The team is kindly asking the community for 22% of these funds to keep developing which is definitely necessary for the Blockchain to continue running, releasing new cool edge cutting features and attracting attention and users. (Which ultimately is what can help token value, so I think team's effort is directed at the right place: development)\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:34 AM]\nNow team is already working on next features and a v2 of the Dex.\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:36 AM]\nThe token holds have a cost of ownership? The team needs funded, Thats inside the treasury details and proposals. Pol fee's need to fund the team, or build the value of the token. Which will ultimately pay the team as they have a stake in ownership for their efforts.\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:37 AM]\nTeam has a salary and a reasonable share of locked tokens, they can't access it now.\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:37 AM]\nalso, team deserves more shares of the tokens if this is the route you wanna propose haha\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:38 AM]\nTEAM: *builds everything*\nTG Chat: i deserve more rewards\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:38 AM]\nThe other thing not communicated is what becomes from the earning of the dex, most dexes make massive amount of money when they have trade volume. This would pay for all development when the user base is here.\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:39 AM]\nimo, i don't think the team is appreciated enough. the tokenomic spread on how much they've allocated for themselves vs everyone else is the best in crypto. Throughout this whole process, they've been always looking out for us and having our back. Giving no one better deals than retail investors. I'll back them to the day i die on this\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:40 AM]\n0.25% of the trading fees go to the LP pools \n0.05% goes to the protocol\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:40 AM]\nTeams dont exist without hard capital. Prove me wrong. There would be no bootstraping needed in this case.\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:40 AM]\nCollectively. That's some good DAO togetherness thinking now\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 6:41 AM]\nAs the others have clarified for you already - the \"fees\" from POL sit in the pool building more POL, but with low volume these are small. The only other fees are transaction fees, which are even smaller, those go to the treasury. And protocol fees, which burn LRNA\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:41 AM]\nA large % of the lp fee's go to pol owned liquidity.\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 6:42 AM]\nReading back through the chat I'm unsure what point you are trying to make?\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 6:42 AM]\nIf you want higher volume we need more assets & deeper liquidity\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:43 AM]\nAs I am stating, if the POL fee's belong to the dao, Buying LRNA does nothing for me.\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:44 AM]\nBuying LRNA?\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:44 AM]\nyou can't buy LRNA\n\nFZSS2842, [2/25/2023 6:44 AM]\nHi everyone. Itâ€™s been a long time since I checked my HydraDX wallet. The Staking option which was available under Network menu is no longer available now!! How can get my staking tokens back?\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:45 AM]\nBuying LRNA, no. This is 100% a team asset. We have no say in LRNA\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:45 AM]\nHi, staking is done. Your HDX should still be in your wallet you were using for the testnet\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:45 AM]\nYou mean burning LRNA. And actually the mor LRNA is burned, the best it is for the price of HDX because it is paired against LRNA\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:46 AM]\nIf you cant buy it, its not a pair\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:46 AM]\nhttps://hydradx.substack.com/p/feeding-every-hydrahead\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:46 AM]\nwhat\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:46 AM]\nHere, \"game theory\" section\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:46 AM]\nI understand its a stop loss\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:46 AM]\nBut you can sell it, so it has a price\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:47 AM]\nYou only earn it by a loss\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:47 AM]\nyes, so idk what you're trying to claim here?\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:47 AM]\nAnd so what. Still paired to other assets.\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:48 AM]\nLRNA is the protocol hub token which every other token is paired against\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:48 AM]\nman this convo has taken like 50 left turns\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:48 AM]\nAnd it earned by experiencing IL\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:48 AM]\nYes I'm not even sure what we're talking about.\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:48 AM]\nyes\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:50 AM]\nYou guys are correct, all of these thing add value to the team.\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:50 AM]\nbro you losing me with \"team\" comments\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 6:50 AM]\n\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:50 AM]\n\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:51 AM]\nI am not talking about whats adding value for the team , i am talking about what adds value to the HDX, which is what i am holding.\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:51 AM]\ni don't even know what we're talking about anymore to be honest\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 6:51 AM]\n\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:52 AM]\nI can loose my entire investment and the team not miss one paycheck.\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:52 AM]\nThen read again please. I'm pretty sure I answered that with different points. I'm pretty proud of myself here actually\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 6:52 AM]\nWhy are you losing your HDX?\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 6:52 AM]\ndo you think the team owns all the LRNA? is that what you're suggesting?\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 6:52 AM]\nDid I miss something\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:52 AM]\nTeam needs to be paid salaries. Not sure what to tell you.\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:54 AM]\nThere is no focus on the token appreciating, or yield for LP holders, which is what attracts new people to the ecosystem.\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 6:54 AM]\nSays who? Is this just your view?\n\nThe Tomiest Tom, [2/25/2023 6:54 AM]\nNot true, liquidity Mining programs are currently being tested on Basilisk first.\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 6:54 AM]\nWhat has lead you to this incorrect view?\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 6:58 AM]\nLook at a price chart. Not going up. we have retrace almost 50%\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 6:59 AM]\nRight. That's due to market forces, I'm asking about your comment \"There is no focus on the token appreciating, or yield for LP holders, which is what attracts new people to the ecosystem.\"\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:00 AM]\nRead our latest blog for an insight into all of the things we are doing to improve the product and attract new people:\n\nhttps://hydradx.substack.com/p/the-future-is-hydrated\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:01 AM]\nWhen you add liquidity, it decreases the share of each lp holder. We are trading at 5% of locked value. You tell me the benefit for the LP holders for doing this?\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:04 AM]\nIf the staking returns, This will help.\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:04 AM]\nthere are future plans for this\n\nrtfw, [2/25/2023 7:04 AM]\nDude just sell everything if you don't like this project\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:04 AM]\nYou dont me to leave\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:04 AM]\nDo you understand that actual volume won't come without sufficient liquidity?\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:05 AM]\nRight now Omnipool is a trading hub for ants\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:05 AM]\nIf we want real volume we need real liquidity\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:06 AM]\nWe have enough to do 10x what we are comfortably. which would pay LP holders and the POL. Bringing on new assets will attract more users\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:08 AM]\nbringing on new assets is adding liquidity which is also what you're against\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:08 AM]\nDude, we won't get 10x volume regularly with this liquidity\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:08 AM]\nLike I say, this is liquidity for ants\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:08 AM]\nWe have eth, btc and dai available . what was new?\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:09 AM]\nDND\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:09 AM]\nPeople aren't going to trade frequently if they're paying multiple % in slippage\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:09 AM]\n\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:10 AM]\nDND is towards the bottom\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:10 AM]\nIncrease liquidity > reduce slippage > reduce costs to trade > get more trade\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:11 AM]\nIt was proven extensively that uniswap dropping LP fees on some pools actually increased trade volume so much that LPs actually earned more fees\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:11 AM]\nMy screen does not show, send me a screenshot\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:11 AM]\nYou don't want a screenshot of Deez Nutz Dude\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:11 AM]\nsorry, i had to haha\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:12 AM]\nI have been offering the dialog that is wanted, and i am offered Deez Nuts\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:13 AM]\nSer you're not offering anything that's wanted right now, just a lot of confusion it seems lol\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:13 AM]\ni joke, just feels like this convo has been going in a circle. you've asked, we've responded, you've asked, we've responded again\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:13 AM]\nYou are not listening.\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:14 AM]\nAre you saying that you are our anonymous referendum blocker and you did it because you think adding more liquidity is against your personal interests?\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:14 AM]\nYou need to work that out with them , I am telling you what i see from my vantage point.\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:15 AM]\nOkay, well FYI you should get down from that vantage point because I think you've gotten altitude sickness or summit\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:15 AM]\neye see\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:16 AM]\n@Kc8iir Increase liquidity > reduce slippage > reduce costs to trade > get more trade\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:16 AM]\ni understand this\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:17 AM]\nSooooooooo why are you moaning that higher liquidity reduces your LP fees\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:17 AM]\n*taps sign*\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:18 AM]\nOnly the team gets yield, I am not allow to get yield?\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:18 AM]\n...\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:18 AM]\n*taps sign*\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:18 AM]\nThis applies for everyone that is LPing\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:18 AM]\nCorrect\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:18 AM]\nThe \"team\" are getting nothing from this\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:19 AM]\nWell, you said the teams are token holders, which is part of the DAO, who gets the LP POL share of the fee's, what a circular argument\n\nSamzonite, [2/25/2023 7:20 AM]\nWhere and how I can check my account balance from 2021, have to calculate how much HDX got from staking etc and trying to find what was my start balance in 2021 ?\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:20 AM]\nBut if your argument is that the team gets the fees because they're token holders then that means you also get the fees because you are a token holder in which case what's the issue\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:21 AM]\nI dont have control of any of those fee's\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:21 AM]\nNot in my wallet\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:21 AM]\nNeither are they in the \"teams\" wallet\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:21 AM]\nThey're in the omnipool just like your LP is\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:22 AM]\nWell, sherlock, now  we have a mystery to solve\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:22 AM]\nThere is no mystery here even though you seem to be struggling somewhat\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:22 AM]\nI dont have an accounting record of that in front of me.\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:24 AM]\nwhat is the benefit of putting the fee's back into Omnipool LP's?\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:25 AM]\nOkay so firstly, they're not \"put back\" - when fees are taken from trades they remain in the pool.\nThis is a very base layer piece of information you need to be aware of\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:26 AM]\nSecondly, greater amounts of assets in the pools means greater amounts of POL, which means greater amounts of fees can be earned. Which means greater amounts of POL. Etc etc\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 7:26 AM]\nIs not possible cause we dont have explorer at that moment, maybe you can search in Etherscan, the xHDX amount that you have\n\nAnd multiply x3 ( due the x3 proposal) (https://hydradx.substack.com/p/road-to-hydration-part-3), so thats would be your \"initial amount\"\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:26 AM]\nEarlier it was said the DAO owns the POL, and the fee's benefit the DAO?\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:26 AM]\nSo all HDX holders (the ones who control the protocol) have more POL/ fees\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:27 AM]\nYes HDX holders = the DAO\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:28 AM]\nincase we forget\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:28 AM]\nSo the wallet address of the DAO reinvestment of fee's into the LP can be seen where?\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:31 AM]\nThere is no \"reinvestment\" - it never leaves the pool\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:31 AM]\nYou can see the share of the pool owned by omnipool & treasury, add them together and that's what the DAO controls\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:34 AM]\nthis one is more on-brand. double post for extra emphasis\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:36 AM]\nThe value of HDX is not correlated to the value the value locked in any POL or the treasury, or am i wrong?\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:43 AM]\nmarket determines value of HDX my guy\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:49 AM]\nYou said earlier the POL fee's benefit the DAO. If the fee's stay in the pool, which does not make the value of hdx go up, where is MY benefit.\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:51 AM]\nimagine this:\nYou and I own a business together. We sell products and make a profit.\nInstead of taking that profit and spending it on strippers and cocaine, we hold onto it to reinvest it in the future.\nYou and I winning.\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 7:51 AM]\nomg dude, as commented above several times\n\nlater the community can propose what to do with the fees collected\n\nHowever, in this instance I am against their use, since the priority would be to generate more POL, so that later on we have more options and not \"kill\" the possibility of evolving.\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:52 AM]\nalthough, idk if i wanna do business with you, you'd rug me at the first paycheck\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:52 AM]\nI have not sold one HDX\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 7:53 AM]\nthe Omnipool was launched 1 month and a half ago \n\nobviously there are many things to improve\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 7:54 AM]\nIn the last proposal there are several things that will make HDX more useful, but now the important thing is to generate traction for Omnipool and more POL\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:54 AM]\nBusinesses have what is called an EQUITY line at the bottom of the balance sheet. My equity does not increase one cent from the fee's left in the POL. Sounds like i am a customer, not a partner.\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 7:54 AM]\n@Kc8iir\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:54 AM]\nyou're literally an owner.\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 7:54 AM]\nyou can propose the idea yourself\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:55 AM]\nif you're vote is to turn on revenue distribution right away, vote for it. and the other owners will vote as well\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 7:55 AM]\nGo to Subsquare, start the discussion, get feedback and start referedum if think will pass\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:55 AM]\nThose are protocol funds, I cant sell one of them\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:55 AM]\nomg\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:55 AM]\nThey are not mine\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 7:56 AM]\nYou claim they are for my benefit, i am asking to understand the claim, Its not baseless.\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 7:56 AM]\nhttps://t.me/hydradx/135916\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 7:56 AM]\nRead it again\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 7:57 AM]\nwe've exhausted ourselves explaining haha\n\nJose Crypto, [2/25/2023 7:57 AM]\nhttps://t.me/hydradx/135926\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:58 AM]\nImagine there are 4 people:\nAlice\nBob\nCharlie\nDylan\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:58 AM]\nThese 4 people own an equal share of a nice juicy pie\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:58 AM]\nBecause they each own 25% of the $PIE token, which is the governance token of the pie\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:59 AM]\nThrough the $PIE tokens, they get to determine what happens with the pie\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 7:59 AM]\nOne day, the pie miraculously grows so there is now a much bigger pie ðŸ˜²\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 8:00 AM]\nAlice Bob Charlie and Dylan still own 25% of the pie each\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 8:00 AM]\nBut the pie is much, much bigger!\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 8:00 AM]\nNow their $PIE tokens oversee control of a much bigger pie\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 8:01 AM]\nThey also have a lot of filling sitting in the fridge\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 8:02 AM]\nPOL earned fee's do not make the value of HDX increase. Increasing the value of hdx would allow a token owner to sell and remove POL, how would it benefit the team if that 10m token guy could sell and remove that much money from the ecosystem? This is why making the value go up is not a priority.\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 8:02 AM]\nBut one day Bob says he doesn't want to add any more filling into the pie because he doesn't benefit from it because he can no longer see the filling\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 8:02 AM]\nEven though it would mean he's got a much bigger pie\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 8:03 AM]\nBob will only let more filling be added to the pie if its directly into his quarter of the pie\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 8:03 AM]\nDon't be like Bob\n\nHello MR G, [2/25/2023 8:04 AM]\nThere is no I in team, only an I in WIN\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 8:05 AM]\nyou in the wrong place then :)\n\nDakauaiguy, [2/25/2023 8:05 AM]\n\nlolmcshizz | HydraDX, [2/25/2023 8:06 AM]\nThere is also no \"Hello MR G\" in \"I've been muted for 24 hours\" but it's happened anyway`","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-26T00:06:06.573Z","editedAt":null,"revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63faa26e89bdb642d535eaaf","cid":null,"height":11},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63faab7d89bdb642d535eab0","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x5ae602686c9573bff2ef0483bda7a9589bc9eb7a2e14f91296367c5785394b27","address":"134Bdvpf4EphtYv1A7Eg5QfrS9ZwGwygdN5uHzqijFjBuhzH","emoji":"🦓","emojiName":"Parakeet","emojiUrl":"https://cdn.discordapp.com/emojis/1074721851550466219.webp?size=32","tag":null,"identity":{"display":"Parakeet","verified":true,"email":"","web":"","twitter":""},"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"Dear “Hello MR G”,\nIt sounds like you were asking:\n1. What is the benefit to the common HDX holder of letting fee earnings accumulate as more POL in omnipool?\n2. What is the benefit to the common LP provider of adding more POL?  \n\nMy thoughts: \nAs a random investor, assessing the value of the HDX token, I would do an analysis similar to what is done for stocks. \n\nIn addition to other things, I would consider the price, market cap, earnings, total amount of capital owned by HDX holders (POL), and some assessment what can be expected in the future. \n\nIf POL is valued more than the fully diluted valuation of HDX, then HDX looks like an attractive buy. HDX shareholders could vote to dissolve the enterprise and come out at breakeven or better. \n\nIf earnings are high, even if POL is less than fully diluted valuation, then HDX looks like an attractive buy because POL is increasing and I can anticipate my investment will become more valuable over time.  \n\nBy letting fees earned by POL accumulate in the omnipool, we are doing the following:\n\nA. **increasing the total capital owned by HDX holders (increasing POL)**. This makes HDX look more attractive to potential new investors. \n\nB. **increasing the liquidity in the omnipool which reduces the price change on large trades**. This increases the value of our product and makes us more competitive. Traders, and thus volume, tends to move toward the most efficient systems. A traders bottom line is to receive as much of asset Y for as little of asset X as they can. Reducing the price impact means traders get more Y for less X. This helps us attract more users. More users means more volume. More volume, more fees. More fees, more earnings for HDX holders (POL increases faster). \n\nC. **increasing the fraction of LP that is protocol controlled**. This reduces the amount of LRNA sold back to the omnipool (unless HDX holders vote to sell LRNA back). Less LRNA sold to the omnipool makes it more likely that the HubAssetImbalance can reach zero and protocol fees can be directed toward increasing the value of HDX. Less LRNA sold back to the omnipool reduces the liquidity drainage experienced by LP providers. LP providers bottom line is to earn as much yield as they can. LRNA sellbacks decrease yield. \n\nIt could be argued that item C also discourages outside LP because a smaller fraction of fees go to outside LP providers. This is true, but generally balanced by the increased volume and trading fees that occur in places with low slippage/price impact. Traders want MAX LP. LP providers want MIN LP, but MAX trade volume. Ultimately, its traders providing the yield, so increasing LP and reducing friction (fees) actually ends up increasing yield except in fully saturated environments that cannot gain additional volume. \n\nA good example is uniswap v3. When the option to reduce fees was added, volume increased such that it is generally more profitable to use the lower fee setting. LP providers charging lower fees see enough extra volume to more than counterbalance the reduced fee per trade. \n\n","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-26T00:44:45.416Z","editedAt":"2023-02-26T00:45:39.541Z","revision":0,"upvotes":1,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63faab7d89bdb642d535eab0","cid":null,"height":12},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63fbfba989bdb642d535eab3","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x6ab1b1ad1a47ec790398e905772a53a8105e337aef258fc5c5aef50eca36bb11","address":"13QtrzZBsCGrFcswz34nK5px6Hj3XimZafoN6VcVQRv89Jub","emoji":"🐩","tag":null,"identity":null,"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"[@amphibiousParakeet](/account/7KejvRw4GZvVjFQEDefAsBRd9iaTjVeUWczB44Mgu8Bue8JW)Thank you for bringing the chat log here. I was expecting a long nasty exchange but surprisingly it seems very calm and level. I did not see any name-calling or personal attacks in the chat other than a weird deez nuts mention.  I can appreciate you reading this thread and breaking it down. You have isolated a lot of points from the conversation. I was unaware of the benefit the team was offering by not paying LRNA on the POL.","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-27T00:39:05.597Z","editedAt":null,"revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63fbfba989bdb642d535eab3","cid":null,"height":13},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]},{"commentId":"s63fc7d2389bdb642d535eab6","parentId":null,"replyToId":null,"author":{"account":{"accountId":"0x9e289d693888d1bf3bcfa508f827240c56ba2e28bf0f7e429d0fb5cfd867ff62","address":"14aNdbS1SCNYm7swFyCA3PMA5tLHGFZCsr7Qvs12i2WfV7kN","emoji":"🐈","emojiName":"sir","emojiUrl":"https://cdn.discordapp.com/emojis/1069817913088946276.webp?size=32","tag":null,"identity":{"display":"ValorHDX","verified":true,"email":"","web":"","twitter":""},"profile":null},"legacyName":null},"body":"We here not for fight but for succes of Hydra project ) So i think issue solved and closed  ?  ","bodyFormat":"markdown","hidden":false,"hiddenReason":null,"deleted":false,"createdAt":"2023-02-27T09:51:31.178Z","editedAt":null,"revision":0,"upvotes":0,"source":{"name":"subsquare","id":"63fc7d2389bdb642d535eab6","cid":null,"height":14},"position":null,"media":{},"replies":[]}],"updates":[],"nextCursor":null,"positionsComplete":null,"locked":false}